Colts Bench Anthony Richardson in Favor of Joe Flacco

In a surprising turn of events from Indianapolis this week, the Colts have opted to bench their second-year starting quarterback, Anthony Richardson. This bold move comes on the heels of reports by ESPN’s Adam Schefter and Jeremy Fowler, revealing that the coaching staff convened on Tuesday morning and decided to replace Richardson with none other than Joe Flacco, a former Super Bowl MVP.

This crucial shift follows a tense game in which Richardson, evidently drained after a play that netted no gain during a vital second-and-goal situation at the Texans’ 23-yard line, signaled to the Colts’ bench that he needed a moment to recover. At the height of the game, he stepped off the field for a breather. In his absence, Indianapolis turned to their star running back, Jonathan Taylor, ultimately settling for a field goal instead of attempting a series of plays that might have secured a touchdown.

The ripple effects of this decision have resonated through the league, sparking a torrent of criticism directed at Richardson from both current players and seasoned veterans. Questions about the young quarterback’s mindset and readiness to lead the franchise have emerged. Richardson's lackluster on-field performance has undoubtedly contributed to his demotion, as he managed to throw for just 175 yards, with one touchdown and one interception on 10-of-32 passing against the Texans. It’s an all-around frustrating and disappointing situation, as Richardson possesses as much talent as anyone in the league. His rocket-like arm and elite quickness in a 6’4" frame make him a tantalizing prospect. Still, the move to Flacco is a justifiable one after last week’s incident.

As the Colts now look to the experienced Flacco, known for his calmness in high-pressure situations, fans and analysts are left speculating on what this means for the team’s trajectory and the hurdles Richardson will need to overcome to reclaim his starting role.